Shipping Policy
Last updated August 2026
How fast we ship, how we pack cards, and what happens if something goes missing.
Processing time
In-stock orders placed before 3:00 PM Eastern on a business day normally ship the same day. Orders after that, or on weekends and holidays, ship the next business day.
Large orders and orders containing preorders may take longer — see below.
Where we ship
We ship throughout the United States. We do not currently ship internationally.
Local pickup is available free at the shop: 1871 Wells Rd, Suite 17, Orange Park, FL 32073. Choose pickup at checkout and we'll email you when your order is ready, usually the same day.
Rates & delivery time
Shipping is calculated at checkout based on the weight and value of your order and the speed you choose. You'll see the exact cost before you pay.
Typical delivery once shipped:
- Standard: 2–5 business days
- Expedited: 1–3 business days
These are carrier estimates, not guarantees. Weather and carrier backlogs happen, and we can't control them once a package is in their hands.
How we pack cards
Every single is sleeved. Cards above a few dollars go into a toploader or semi-rigid holder, and the stack is secured so it can't shift in transit. Graded slabs are padded on all sides.
Sealed product ships in a right-sized box with fill — we don't ship booster boxes in bubble mailers.
Orders over $100 ship with tracking and require signature or include insurance at our discretion, to protect both of us.
Preorders
Preorders ship as close to the official release date as our distributor allotment allows, normally within 1–2 business days of the product landing.
If your order contains both in-stock items and a preorder, we hold the whole order and ship it together unless you ask us to split it. Ask — we're happy to, though a split may mean paying shipping twice.
Tracking
You'll get a shipping confirmation email with tracking as soon as your label is created. Tracking can take up to 24 hours to start updating after that — a label that hasn't moved yet is normal and doesn't mean anything went wrong.
Nothing after 3 business days? Email us and we'll look into it.
Lost or damaged in transit
If a package arrives damaged, keep all the packaging and photograph the box and contents, then contact us within 7 days so we can file a carrier claim and take care of you.
For packages tracking says are delivered but that you don't have, contact us and we'll help you chase the carrier. See our refund policy for how these are resolved.
Address accuracy
Check your shipping address before you pay. We ship to the address exactly as entered, and we can't reroute a package once it's with the carrier.
Orders returned to us as undeliverable are refunded minus the original shipping cost. Email us right away if you catch a mistake — if we haven't printed the label yet, we can fix it.